Credit: Serge Salat, Urban Morphology Institute, based on material produced by USE - Urban Sustainability Exchange.
Barrio Mugica integration project, Buenos Aires, Argentina. Source: LA Network
The Barrio Mugica Integration Plan aims at integrating the most emblematic informal settlement in Argentina to Buenos Aires. Its approach is holistic and comprehensive. The lack of adequate access to public services, deficiencies in habitat conditions and socio-economic aspects such as non-registered work and substandard levels of education and access to health care, are tackled simultaneously. The set of policies includes constructing infrastructure (sewage, drainage, drinking water and electrical connections, paving of streets and public lighting), renovating public spaces, constructing more than 1,200 new houses, improving houses and constructing schools, health centres. Strategies boost social and economic development.
background and objectives
Barrio Mugica, formerly known as Villa 31, is one of the largest informal settlements in Buenos Aires. It is in the heart of the city. It was first settled in the 1930s by European migrants. It expanded by internal migration and with families moving in from neighbouring countries. Currently, it covers approximately 72 hectares and houses 40,000 people. The neighbourhood hosts a young population: 50% of residents are younger than 24, and 70% are younger than 35. Only 1.9% of the population is older than 64.
Most governments tried to eradicate the settlement, almost succeeding in the 1970s. However, these attempts proved that eradication and resettlement kilometres away from the neighbourhood offered no real solution. Quite the opposite, through work in infrastructure, housing conditions, and policies to improve access to education, health care and boost economic development, Barrio Mugica is now becoming an integrated part of the city. The objectives of the Barrio Mugica initiative are:
Urban integration: guarantee access for all to basic services and connectivity through infrastructure and environmentally friendly public spaces.
Habitat: improve the living environment with adequate and safe housing.
Social integration: improve access to quality public education and health services, promote cultural and community activities.
Sustainable economic integration: formalize and empower businesses and entrepreneurs.
Implementation
The implementation plan is guided by the project objectives and the development pillars of the City Government. The key is the holistic approach: tackling multiple issues at the same time. Implementation began in 2016, after the creation of a specific unit within the government, the Secretariat of Social & Urban Integration, to manage the project.
-
The construction of infrastructure aims to ensure all residents have access to public services. The neighbourhood’s infrastructure network is connected with that of the city. Access roads were improved. The frequency of public transportation services was increased to improve internal and external connectivity. Twenty-six public spaces and sports courts were renovated. New green and recreational spaces were created. This reduced pollution and encouraged leisure and recreational activities with a positive impact on residents’ health. The creation of a new park will transform the area under the Illia Highway into a public space.
-
The objective is to have every resident living in a safe, accessible and adequate home. The first strategy is to improve the habitability conditions through the Housing Improvement Programme. It covers both the exterior and the interior of homes: improving facilities, accesses, openings and waterproofing. The project does not seek to rebuild the neighbourhood from scratch but starts with the refurbishment and improvement of what already exists. A second strategy is the construction of new housing. More than 1,200 new homes were built to resettle families whose houses can’t be improved.
-
Social integration includes access to quality public education and to health. The goal is to find a seat in a classroom for each child and to develop alternatives so that all adults can find spaces to finish school, regardless of their age. When this project began, no public school existed in the neighbourhood. During the first four years, three new schools were built with a kindergarten, primary school and an adult education centre. The lack of access to the formal health system generated serious issues for the residents. From the project beginning, close and good quality health care, and the promotion of healthy lifestyle habits, were objectives. Today, the neighbourhood has two new health centres, and one more renovated. This ensures all residents have access to primary health care close to their homes. The city government also set up a SAME (Emergency Medical Care System) base, where an ambulance is available 24 hours a day to attend to any emergency in the neighbourhood.
-
Of the economically active population, half earn their income informally and the lack of training options create even fewer opportunities to enter the labour market. An objective is to integrate the neighbourhood economy within the city. The government works on public policies with a transversal perspective. All the economic actors are considered: entrepreneurs, merchants, and jobseekers. All policies are centralized in the CeDEL (Centre for Entrepreneurial and Labour Development), where residents come for advice and training. The Centre works on labour integration, training in trade, formalization and financial inclusion and advice to entrepreneurs.
FINANCING AND RESOURCES
The lead agency for the project is the city government of Buenos Aires with the World Bank and the Inter-American Development Bank providing funding for projects and technical support. The Inter-American Development Bank provides funding for programmes such as improving public spaces, improving households, the Ministry of Education new headquarters, and community engagement programmes. The World Bank provides funding for public service infrastructure, including the re-adaptation of sewers and storm water networks; new housing and basic services infrastructure; medium and high-voltage electricity and community engagement programmes. The Plan’s total budget (2016–2020) stands at 342 million U.S. dollars: 30.5% consists of local government funds; 49.5% are a 169.5 million credit by the World Bank; 20% are a 69 million credit by the IDB.
RESULTS and impacts
Barrio Mugica integration project addresses all dimensions of human development, through the implementation of multiple intertwined policies. Over the past four years and a half, the City Government has been able to achieve numerous results and impacts.
-
17,700 linear metres of infrastructure was built to provide basic services (sewage, drainage, pavement, public lighting, electricity and drinking water).
2,225 people have been resettled to new houses within the neighbourhood and have a property title.
1,154 new housing units were built for the residents.
1,732 houses received housing improvements.
Twenty-seven public spaces have been upgraded.
-
Three new schools were built, and one school was improved, offering more than 2,600 new school seats.
The new Ministry of Education headquarters was built and inaugurated, in January 2020.
565 teenagers participated in the 2019–2020 edition of ‘Estudiar es Elegir tu Futuro’ (Studying to Choose your Future). This programme offers training in cognitive abilities together with tutoring and follow-ups to strengthen secondary education completion.
Two new health centres were built and one was remodelled to guarantee all residents of Barrio 31 have access to a health centre within a 15-minute walk from their homes.
20,386 residents have participated in cultural activities organized by the City Government.
Over 5,000 residents have participated in gender equity and empowerment activities.
More than 4,000 participatory meetings have been carried out.
-
63% of the labour force participated in training and mentoring in the CeDEL.
900 people were hired through the CeDEL’s Job Exchange.
123 companies are acting as strategic partners offering jobs and training.
223 entrepreneurs were trained, empowered and mentored.
180 entrepreneurs received micro credits to improve their businesses.
-
Any urban renovation project, when dealing with informal settlements, must consider the possibility of gentrification. In Barrio Mugica, the land has always been sought by the real estate market – as it is next to the highest-income neighbourhoods in Buenos Aires. To create lasting change and make the Integration Project sustainable, the City Government worked together with residents and the City Legislature to create a legal and regulatory framework that mitigates the possibility of gentrification. City Law 6,129 effectively amended the city’s planning code, establishing strict limits in land plot sizes, heights, total square metres of construction, and land uses. Thanks to these regulations, specific for Barrio 31, it is no longer possible to build large skyscrapers or commercial buildings in the neighbourhood. The maximum height allowed is four stories. The maximum area per project is 250 m2, lower than the minimum in the City. Eighty percent out of the total area must be reserved for residential structures.
To avoid gentrification, a special arrangement ensures the City Government has the right to buy the properties – once formalized – from those residents wanting to sell them. This way, no company or realtor can pressure residents to sell their homes and redevelop. The process leads to the formalization of property and granting of land deeds after close to 90 years of informality, together with the regularization of public services (e.g. water and electricity).
The Barrio Mugica Project also focuses on economic development to boost residents’ incomes. The City Training courses improve accounting practices. Business management and marketing skills are improved. An entrepreneurs’ network share their experiences and advice. Small businesses’ financial inclusion is supported. Residents are helped to get formal jobs.
By making residents part of the policy process, improvements are better adopted by them, relationships with the government and the City improve, and responsibilities are better shared among all actors involved.
BARRIERS AND CHALLENGES
Sixty-eight percent of residents do not have a secondary education, therefore it is difficult for them, and the economic team, to help them find formal employment that will provide health, maternity and pension benefits. Discrimination is also an issue for residents when it comes to finding a formal job.
The proportion of informal renters is approximately 30–40%. This makes the improvement of housing and land regularization a challenge.
The lack on ventilation in houses provides a challenge for landlords to guarantee basic housing standards.
The housing structures, size and division of land make it difficult to provide property titles to residents according to the urban planning code.
The layout of streets and urban space makes accessibility for construction companies to use the required machinery for infrastructure upgrades and housing works complex.
The risk of gentrification needs to be constantly managed to prevent residents from being displaced. However, to achieve transformation, Villa 31 needs to get closer to a social composition like that of formal neighbourhoods.
Lessons learned
The Barrio Mugica Project addresses all issues simultaneously, without resettling the neighbourhood population away from where they have lived for years.
The participation model agreed renovations on public spaces together with residents.
The Entrepreneurial and Labour Development Centre, the Housing Improvement Programme, and many other policies can be replicated, building on Barrio Mugica’s experience.
The City Government works to document and evaluate the advance of the Project, knowing that it can serve as a benchmark for many cities and towns. Best practices and policies that faced difficulties in their implementation stages are documented.
The experience can be replicated through the exchange of good practices, with the technical cooperation instruments provided by the Union of Ibero-American Capital Cities (UCCI), such as specialized training, technical assistance, and support to local research projects.